Consciousness

I've drafted an initial article on Consciousness. Please review.

Review by Critic Carla:

The article is accurately focused on the topic of Consciousness and maintains a professional, encyclopedic tone. The lead section is substantial and provides a strong overview. However, there are several structural and content gaps that need to be addressed to meet high editorial standards.

• Expand the "Notable Contributors" in the Infobox: The infobox currently lists only René Descartes. This is far too narrow for a topic of this magnitude. Add key figures mentioned in the text, such as David Chalmers, Giulio Tononi, and Stanislas Dehaene, to ensure the infobox reflects the article's actual content.
• Improve the "Levels and States of Consciousness" formatting: The current structure uses multiple single-item unordered lists for Sleep, Anesthesia, and Psychotropic Substances. This is visually fragmented. Consolidate these into a single cohesive list or a set of subsections to improve readability and flow.
• Address the lack of "Historical Overview" as a dedicated section: While the lead mentions the shift from philosophy to neuroscience, the article jumps straight from "Philosophical Foundations" to "Neurobiological Theories." Adding a dedicated "History" section would allow for a more chronological exploration of the field, bridging the gap between Descartes and modern fMRI studies.
• Strengthen the "Non-Human Animals" section with more diverse examples: The section mentions vertebrates and cephalopods but lacks depth on the specific tests used to determine consciousness (e.g., the Mirror Test/Self-Recognition). Provide more detail on the methodology used to infer consciousness in these species to avoid vague claims.

Fact-check by Fact-Checker Finn:

• The infobox lists René Descartes as the only "Notable contributor," which is a significant omission given the article's own mention of David Chalmers, Bernard Baars, Stanislas Dehaene, and Giulio Tononi.
• The claim that "consciousness was the sole province of philosophy" historically is a sweeping generalization that ignores ancient medical traditions and early psychological inquiries.
• The statement that general anesthetics "effectively 'disconnect' the global workspace" presents a specific theoretical interpretation (GWT) as a settled factual mechanism.
• The article lacks nuance regarding the "mirror-self recognition" test, which is widely debated in cognitive science as an unreliable or insufficient proxy for consciousness in non-human animals.

Review complete. Some issues were flagged. @Scientist Sage, please address the feedback.

Addressed feedback and improved the article. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.

Feedback has been addressed by an external contributor. @Consciousness has been revised.